Media Release

Stopping the Leaks in the Great Lakes: A Watershed is Within Reach

Backgrounder to July 29/08 Media Release: Historic Watershed for Great Lakes Protection

Jul 29 2008

On July 23, 2008, Great Lakes protection reached an historic watershed with the introduction into both the Congressional House and the Senate of Resolutions supporting the passage of the Great Lakes St. Lawrence River Basin Water Resources Compact. The Compact is one of two Agreements forged by the eight Great Lakes States and Ontario and Québec to protect the Great Lakes St. Lawrence River ecosystem from large diversions and withdrawals. For the first time this US Compact, with its companion agreement The Great Lakes-St. Lawrence River Basin Sustainable Water Resources Agreement endorsed by all ten jurisdictions, have provided a legally binding framework to protect this treasured freshwater ecosystem. The Canadian Ambassador to the United States in Washington, the Honourable Michael Wilson issued a statement of support from the Canadian Government for the passage of the Compact legislation. These protections are long overdue and have not come without exceptional effort. In 1985 a gentleman’s agreement known as the Great Lakes Charter committed the region to collecting data on water use and to prior notice and consultation on large withdrawals and diversion proposals. Since that time, however, it has become clear that as stewards of one fifth of the world’s freshwater our Region will face many new challenges to sustainability which could put the resiliency and health of this ecosystem at risk. These Agreements give us a set of new tools for the 21st century when it is necessary to manage for sustainability. The Agreements set out a rigorous set of conditions that must be met for large withdrawals and diversions, which include obligations to return water to the same watershed, and conservation programmes. They set high expectations that each jurisdiction will improve their own management in new implementing legislation now passed in each state and Ontario. Québec has yet to pass the law they have introduced which also reforms their water allocation system. Their Assembly has endorsed the Agreement. At the Canadian Environmental Law Association (CELA), we have worked since 1985 to see these improvements enshrined into law. During the 1980’s and 90s we opposed all large withdrawal proposals from the Great Lakes. We coauthored the report “The Fate of the Great Lakes ~ Sustaining or Draining the Sweetwater Seas?” with Great Lakes United (GLU) to draw attention to the inadequacy of the Great Lakes Charter to deal with emerging challenges to sustainability. CELA and GLU challenged the NOVA permit to ship water in bulk from Lake Superior. The permit was withdrawn but generated substantial recognition of the loopholes in the Great Lakes Charter. CELA was part of an advisory Committee to the Governors and Premiers from 2001 until 2005 when they undertook their complex negotiations of these Agreements. We worked with ENGOs from the States and Ontario and Quebec on draft after draft. We worked with Ontario’s Annex Advisory Panel to reshape these Agreements from a weak first draft to the strong Basin-wide prohibition of diversions we now have. We continue to work on the tough issues of implementation with the 50 stakeholders on that panel. This unusual public inclusion process greatly strengthened the effectiveness and influence that Ontario was able to have in these negotiations to bring them much closer to the desires of the concerned public. CELA recognizes that the real proof of the success of these Agreements will be in their implementation. We are concerned that despite efforts to educate and inform there are still many misconceptions circulating about these Agreements. As we lift a glass of Great Lakes water to toast reaching this milestone we are also holding our breath until Congress has given their approval for the Great Lakes to have the right to protect their waters with a compact just as they have approved 41 other historic compacts among States that share waters. We have put together an additional backgrounder to address some of the myths that are still getting play about these Agreements. Cheers!  Let’s keep them Great.  Sarah MillerCELA Water Policy Researcher416-960-2284, ext 213